Choosing between a solo 401(k) plan (also known as a one-participant 401(k) plan) and a simplified employee pension (SEP) plan is kind of like choosing between a ribeye from Morton’s or one from Ruth’s Chris — both are excellent options. Let’s take a closer look at the benefits of both plans and the situations for which each is particularly well suited.
Three Benefits Of A Solo 401(k) Versus A SEP Plan
Both types of retirement plans are good options for saving, and it’s always best to have some type of savings plan in place to help provide enough money to last the duration of your retirement. For some retirement investors, putting their money into a solo 401(k) can be more advantageous because these plans provide more flexibility.
Here are the three main benefits a solo 401(k) offers over a SEP:
- Solo 401(k) loan. With a solo 401(k), you can borrow up to 50% of the total balance with a $50,000 cap. If you pay the loan back on time, there are no taxes or penalties for borrowing from yourself. In essence, you become your own rich uncle. Loans typically must be paid back in five years, or 15 years if the loan is used to purchase a primary residence. The loan can be used for any purpose.
- Self-directed. Opening a SEP typically requires using an individual retirement account (IRA) custodian. However, with a solo 401(k), you act as the plan’s custodian. Since you are the plan’s administrator and its trustee, you can manage investments from your IRA without needing to work through a third-party administrator. You also can save on fees since there aren’t any administrative or management fees with a solo 401(k).
- Roth IRA conversion option. There’s no Roth IRA conversion option for SEPs, and Roth IRAs provide some key tax advantages. All Roth contributions are made with post-tax dollars, so portfolio growth is 100% tax-free.
Three Benefits Of A SEP Plan Versus A Solo 401(k)
SEP plans are primarily used to help employees of small businesses create their retirement nest eggs. Business owners can make contributions up to 25% of each employee’s pay — employees aren’t eligible to make contributions to their SEP IRAs. Contributions are tax-deductible for employers, and growth accrues tax-free until the employee retires and begins taking distributions.
Here are three main reasons why a SEP IRA may make sense for certain individuals and small business owners over a solo 401(k):
- Easy setup. Unlike most qualified employer-sponsored IRAs, which have high setup and custodial management fees, SEP IRAs are easy to establish and have low administrative costs. Plus, plan expenses may also be tax-deductible.
- Available for any size business. While solo 401(k)s are primarily used by individuals and independent contractors with no employees, SEP IRAs can be established by a wide range of business owners, including partnerships, corporations and sole proprietors.
- Discretionary contributions. Since employers are responsible for all contributions to the SEP IRA, they can forgo contributions in times of economic distress or low annual profits.
Contribution limits with both SEP IRAs and solo 401(k) plans for 2019 are $56,000. However, solo 401(k) plans allow for a “catch-up” contribution of up to $6,000 if you are over age 50, which boosts the annual contribution limit to $62,000. Since employers make all contributions to SEP IRAs, there’s no option for employees to make catch-up deferrals.
Both plans can be advantageous in certain situations. Solo 401(k) plans can be easier to self-manage because they require less paperwork than SEP IRAs, which require filing an IRS form 5498 annually regardless of the account’s value. A SEP IRAs may be ideal for small businesses whose employees are financially limited and therefore might not be able to make significant contributions to their retirement accounts, while a solo 401(k) may be the better option for people who can afford to make the lion’s share of contributions to their retirement savings. Ultimately, the choice of either type of retirement savings plan should be weighed carefully and discussed with a financial professional.